Sentencing for Sexual Offences: Difference between revisions

From Criminal Law Notebook
Line 5: Line 5:
; Ranges
; Ranges
Sentencing for sexual offence, whether the victim is under age or not, must emphasize the "wrongfulness and harmfulness" of the offences by taking into account the "life-altering consequences" of the offences.<ref>
Sentencing for sexual offence, whether the victim is under age or not, must emphasize the "wrongfulness and harmfulness" of the offences by taking into account the "life-altering consequences" of the offences.<ref>
{{CanLIIR|Brown|jb498|2020 ONCA 657 (CanLII)}}{{perONCA|Trotter JA}}{{atL|jb498|59}} - extending principles from Friesen to adult offences
{{CanLIIRP|Brown|jb498|2020 ONCA 657 (CanLII)|152 OR (3d) 650}}{{perONCA|Trotter JA}}{{atL|jb498|59}} - extending principles from Friesen to adult offences
</ref>
</ref>



Revision as of 20:55, 12 May 2021

General Principles

Ranges

Sentencing for sexual offence, whether the victim is under age or not, must emphasize the "wrongfulness and harmfulness" of the offences by taking into account the "life-altering consequences" of the offences.[1]

Consent

De facto consent of the victim is not an appropriate form of mitigation.[2]

Terminology

The use of terms such as "fondling" or "caressing" should be avoided as it tends to minimize the violence involved.[3]

  1. R v Brown, 2020 ONCA 657 (CanLII), 152 OR (3d) 650, per Trotter JA, at para 59 - extending principles from Friesen to adult offences
  2. See Victims as a Factor in Sentencing
  3. R v Friesen, 2020 SCC 9 (CanLII), per Wagner CJ and Rowe J

Child Sexual Offences

Position of Trust

Position of Trust as a Factor in Sentencing

Historical Sex Offences

Historical Sexual Offences should not have their penalties reduced simply because of the time that has passed between the offence and sentence. The magnitude and culpability remain the same. [1] The importance of denunciation and deterrence as primary sentencing objectives are not diminished.[2]

However, the passage of time can show that the offender is a low risk to re-offend and that the offence is not in the character of the offender.

Case Digests

See Also