Reverse Onus Provisions Under Section 515

From Criminal Law Notebook
Revision as of 22:37, 13 February 2024 by Admin (talk | contribs)
This page was last substantively updated or reviewed January 2024. (Rev. # 90874)

General Principles

That is, unless the charge falls within the offences listed in s.515 (6):

515
[omitted (1), (2), (2.01), (2.02), (2.03), (2.1), (2.2), (2.3), (3), (4), (4.1), (4.11), (4.12), (4.2), (4.3) and (5)]

Order of detention

(6) Unless the accused, having been given a reasonable opportunity to do so, shows cause why the accused’s detention in custody is not justified, the justice shall order, despite any provision of this section, that the accused be detained in custody until the accused is dealt with according to law, if the accused is charged

(a) with an indictable offence, other than an offence listed in section 469 [exclusive jurisdiction offences],
(i) that is alleged to have been committed while at large after being released in respect of another indictable offence pursuant to the provisions of this Part or section 679 [release pending appeal] or 680 [review by court of appeal],
(ii) that is an offence under section 467.11 [participation in activities of criminal organization], 467.111 [recruitment of members by a criminal organization], 467.12 [commission of offence for criminal organization] or 467.13 [instructing commission of offence for criminal organization], or a serious offence alleged to have been committed for the benefit of, at the direction of, or in association with, a criminal organization,
(iii) that is an offence under any of sections 83.02 to 83.04 [financing of terrorism offences] and 83.18 to 83.23 [participating, facilitating, instructing and harbouring terrorist offences] or otherwise is alleged to be a terrorism offence,
(iv) an offence under subsection 16(1) or (2), 17(1), 19(1), 20(1) or 22(1) of the Security of Information Act,
(v) an offence under subsection 21(1) or 22(1) or section 23 of the Security of Information Act that is committed in relation to an offence referred to in subparagraph (iv),
(vi) that is an offence under section 95 [possession of prohibited or restricted firearm with ammunition], 98 [breaking and entering to steal firearm], 98.1 [robbery to steal firearm], 99 [weapons trafficking], 100 [possession for purpose of weapons trafficking], 102 [making automatic firearm] or 103 [importing or exporting firearms knowing it is unauthorized],
(vii) that is an offence under section 244 [discharging firearm] or 244.2 [discharging firearm – recklessness], or an offence under section 239 [attempted murder], 272 [sexual assault with a weapon or causing bodily harm] or 273 [aggravated sexual assault], subsection 279(1) [kidnapping] or section 279.1 [hostage taking], 344 [robbery] or 346 [extortion] that is alleged to have been committed with a firearm, or
(viii) that is alleged to involve, or whose subject-matter is alleged to be, a firearm, a cross-bow, a prohibited weapon, a restricted weapon, a prohibited device, any ammunition or prohibited ammunition or an explosive substance, and that is alleged to have been committed while the accused was under a prohibition order within the meaning of subsection 84(1) [firearms and other weapons — definitions], including a release order made under this section, that prohibited the accused from possessing any of those things;
(b) with an indictable offence, other than an offence listed in section 469 [exclusive jurisdiction offences] and is not ordinarily resident in Canada,
(b.1) with an offence in the commission of which violence was allegedly used, threatened or attempted against their intimate partner, and the accused has been previously convicted or discharged under section 730 [order of discharge] of an offence in the commission of which violence was used, threatened or attempted against any intimate partner of theirs;
(b.2) with an offence in the commission of which violence was allegedly used, threatened or attempted against a person with the use of a weapon, and the accused has been previously convicted, within five years of the day on which they were charged for that offence, of another offence in the commission of which violence was also used, threatened or attempted against any person with the use of a weapon, if the maximum term of imprisonment for each of those offences is 10 years or more;
(c) with an offence under any of subsections 145(2) to (5) [provisions re failure to comply] that is alleged to have been committed while they were at large after being released in respect of another offence under the provisions of this Part or section 679 [release pending appeal], 680 [review by court of appeal] or 816 [release order for appellant]; or
(d) with having committed an offence punishable by imprisonment for life under any of sections 5 to 7 of the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act or the offence of conspiring to commit such an offence.
Reasons

(6.1) If the justice orders that an accused to whom subsection (6) [reverse onus offences[1]] applies be released, the justice shall include in the record a statement of the justice’s reasons for making the order.

Release order

(7) If an accused to whom subsection (6) [reverse onus offences[2]] applies shows cause why their detention in custody is not justified, the justice shall make a release order under this section. If the accused was already at large on a release order, the new release order may include any additional conditions described in subsections (4) to (4.2) that the justice considers desirable.
(8) [Repealed, 2019, c. 25, s. 225(7)]

Sufficiency of record

(9) For the purposes of subsections (5) [detention in custody] and (6) [reverse onus offences[3]], it is sufficient if a record is made of the reasons in accordance with the provisions of Part XVIII [Pt. XVIII – Procedure on Preliminary Inquiry (ss. 535 to 551)] relating to the taking of evidence at preliminary inquiries.

Written reasons

(9.1) Despite subsection (9) [sufficiency of record], if the justice orders that the accused be detained in custody primarily because of a previous conviction of the accused, the justice shall state that reason, in writing, in the record.
[omitted (10), (11), (12), (13) and (14)]
R.S., 1985, c. C-46, s. 515; R.S., 1985, c. 27 (1st Supp.), ss. 83, 186; 1991, c. 40, s. 31; 1993, c. 45, s. 8; 1994, c. 44, s. 44; 1995, c. 39, s. 153; 1996, c. 19, ss. 71, 93.3; 1997, c. 18, s. 59, c. 23, s. 16; 1999, c. 5, s. 21, c. 25, s. 8(Preamble); 2001, c. 32, s. 37, c. 41, ss. 19, 133; 2008, c. 6, s. 37; 2009, c. 22, s. 17, c. 29, s. 2; 2010, c. 20, s. 1; 2012, c. 1, s. 32; 2014, c. 17, s. 14; 2015, c. 13, s. 20; 2018, c. 16, s. 218; 2019, c. 25, s. 225; 2021, c. 27, s. 4; 2022, c. 17, s. 32(E); 2023, c. 7, s. 1; 2023, c. 30, s. 1.

CCC (CanLII), (DOJ)


Note up: 515(6), (6.1), (7), (9), and (9.1)

For the purpose of reverse onus, "indictable offences" includes hybrid offences, but not those in which there was a summary election.[4]

Where a person is charged with multiple offences, only some of which are reverse onus offences, the non-reverse onus offences do not change onus.[5]

When the accused is a young person. The YCJA governs the onus on bail.

Constitutionality

The reverse onus for offences under s. 469 is constitutional.[6]

Criminal Organization Offences

Section 515(6)(a)(ii) provides that the following offences are subject to a reverse onus:

  • s. 467.11,
  • s. 467.111,
  • s. 467.12
  • s. 467.13,
  • a "serious offence" committed "for the benefit of, at the direction of, or in association with, a criminal organization".

The term "serious offence" is defined in s. 467.1:

467.1 (1)...
"serious offence" means an indictable offence under this or any other Act of Parliament for which the maximum punishment is imprisonment for five years or more, or another offence that is prescribed by regulation. ...
[omitted (2), (3) and (4)]
1997, c. 23, s. 11; 2001, c. 32, s. 27; 2014, c. 17, s. 8.

CCC (CanLII), (DOJ)


Note up: 467.1(1)

The term is expanded by the Regulations Prescribing Certain Offences to be Serious Offences, SOR/2010-161, which adds the following offences:

(a) keeping a common gaming or betting house (subsection 201(1) and paragraph 201(2)(b));
(b) betting, pool-selling and book-making (section 202); (c) committing offences in relation to lotteries and games of chance (section 206);
(d) cheating while playing a game or in holding the stakes for a game or in betting (section 209); and
(e) keeping a common bawdy-house (subsection 210(1) and paragraph 210(2)(c)).

...

(a) trafficking in any substance included in Schedule IV (paragraph 5(3)(c)); [Barbiturates ...]
(b) trafficking in any substance included in Schedule II in an amount that does not exceed the amount set out for that substance in Schedule VII (subsection 5(4)); [Cannabis...]
(c) importing or exporting any substance included in Schedule IV or V (paragraph 6(3)(c)); and [Barbiturates or Propylhexedrine (stimulant related to methamphetamine)]
(d) producing any substance included in Schedule IV (paragraph 7(2)(d)); [Barbiturates...]

Regs

  1. Found elsewhere in this same page.
  2. Found elsewhere in this same page.
  3. Found elsewhere in this same page.
  4. R v Cooper, 2007 NSSC 224 (CanLII), (2007) 256 NSR (2d) 200 (NSSC), per Coughlan J
    R v Hopkins, 2004 BCSC 1383 (CanLII), [2004] BCJ No 2273 (BCSC), per Barrow J
    R v Taylor, [2001] OJ No 2625(*no CanLII links) - crown elected summary conviction but still treated as "indictable" for purpose of bail
  5. see R v Villota, 2002 CanLII 49650 (ONSC), 163 CCC (3d) 507, per Hill J, at para 78
  6. R v Sanchez, 1999 CanLII 4220 (NSCA), 136 CCC (3d) 31, per Chipman JA

Section 469 Offences

See Also