Kidnapping and Unlawful Confinement (Sentencing Cases)

This page was last substantively updated or reviewed December 2023. (Rev. # 89404)

• < Sentencing
• < Cases

Case Digests

Case Name	Prv.	Crt.	Sentence	Summary
R v Codrington, 2023 ONSC 6352 (CanLII), per Akhtar J	ON	SC	10 years imprisonment	Find summaries of case.
R v Okito, 2023 ONSC 1514 (CanLII), per Forestell J	ON	SC		Find summaries of case.
R v Rajkovic, 2021 ONCA 11 (CanLII), per MacPherson JA	ON	CA	8 years (kidnapping) 8 years (robbery)	Find summaries of case.
R v Baskaran, 2020 ONCA 25 (CanLII), per Nordheimer JA	ON	CA		Find other summaries.
R v Dillon, 2017 SKCA 28 (CanLII), per Lane JA	SK	CA	3 years (kidnapping) 30 day (breaches x2)	The offender pleaded guilty to kidnapping and breach of conditions x 2. Find other summaries.
R v Paradis, 2016 BCPC 354 (CanLII), per Doulis J	BC	PC	6 months (confinement) 6 months (threats) 14 and 45 days (breach)	The offender pleaded guilty to confinement, uttering threats, and two counts of breaches. The offender assaulted his domestic partner by hitting her up to 70 times, choked her, and threatened her if she attempted to leave the trailer they were in. Find other summaries.
R v Ghodsi, 2013 ABCA 337 (CanLII), per Berger JA	AB	CA	2.5 years imprisonment	The offender took his 3 and 8 year old children to Iran for vacation and never returned. He was not charged until 8 years later. Find other summaries.
R v Cook, 2013 MBQB 100 (CanLII), per Martin J	MB	SC	9 years imprisonment (kidnapping) 7.5 years imprisonment (sexual assault)	"in the early morning hours, the victim was walking down a public street using crutches and one arm in a cast. The offender, who was a complete stranger to the victim, grabbed her by the neck, dragged her a short distance to the house where he was staying and forced vaginal intercourse, fellatio and attempted anal intercourse while choking her. After two unsuccessful attempts to escape, the victim escaped when the offender fell asleep. The offender, who was in his 40’s, had a prior record for crimes of violence but no prior sexual offences, choking or kidnapping charges. The offender was intoxicated at the time of the offences, his criminal activity was not planned and he suffered from a disadvantaged aboriginal background as well as alcohol abuse. The Court regarded this as a very serious series of offences in stating at para. 21 that “it is hard to imagine a more chilling scenario for a woman then to be dragged off a street, held and raped and choked until she is able to escape half naked. It is a vile, sordid assault that must be clearly condemned”. The Court ordered nine years of imprisonment for the kidnapping charge, seven and a half years concurrent for the sexual assault charge and one and a half years consecutive to the sexual assault charge for the choking charge, but concurrent to the kidnapping charge. The total sentence imposed was nine years less time served in custody on remand, for a go-forward sentence of seven years and eight months." (Quoting from R v Lemoine, 2014 NSPC 49) Find other summaries.
R v White, 2012 ONCJ 619 (CanLII), per Devlin J	ON	PC	2 years less a day	The offender built dungeon in basement of building to kidnap friend of ex-wife. He was also sentenced for break and enter of building. Find summaries of case.
R v Singh, 2011 ONCJ 394 (CanLII), per Robertson J	ON	PC	6 months (confinement) 3.5 years (global)	The offender was found guilty of s.88, 264.1, and forceable confinement of wife. He assaulted his wife with a pipe and forced her into house to hide from authorities. He had no record and was on house arrest for 34 months pending this case. He was remorseful. There were serious long-standing injuries to victim.
R v McCann, 2011 BCSC 1590 (CanLII), per Schultes J	BC	SC	2 years less a day imprisonment (confinement) 2 years less a day imprisonment (assault CBH)	Find summaries of case.
R v Oxford, 2009 CanLII 70905 (NLPC), per Gorman J	NL	PC	12 months imprisonment	The offender was also sentenced on poss'n of weapon (88) and breaches. He confined wife in the house at knife-point.
R v Power, 2008 NLTD 6 (CanLII), per Thompson J	NL	SC	5 months (confinement) 16 months (global)	The offender was also sentenced for assault, uttering threats, and breaches. He assaulted his wife on numerous occasions. The offender would not let accused out of vehicle. Find other summaries.
R v Tahvili, 2008 BCSC 22 (CanLII), per Joyce J	BC	SC		(Quoting from R v , [1]) Find other summaries.
R v Radisic, 2008 ONCA 822 (CanLII), per curiam	ON	CA		"the accused was convicted of a number of offences, including kidnapping, uttering threats, assault, assault with a weapon and aggravated assault. He and other persons kidnapped three individuals in an effort to locate a drug dealer who had stolen some drugs from the accused. The abduction lasted for two days and at times significant violence was used. At other times the captors were friendly towards the victims and provided them with food, alcohol and drugs. The accused was 30 years of age, addicted to drugs, had a significant criminal record and showed no remorse towards his victims. The offences were committed while he was on probation. Crown suggested a range of global sentence of 5 to 7 years, while defence suggested a range of 2 to 7 years. The trial judge concluded the appropriate range was 4 to 7 years and sentences the accused to an effective 5 year global sentence." (Quoting from R v Tahvili, 2008 BCSC 22) Find other summaries.
R v Ayach, 2007 BCSC 398 (CanLII), per J	BC	SC		"the court applied the four to six year range given in Mills and imposed an effective sentence of four years in a case in which a 28 year old accused pleaded guilty to kidnapping and aggravated assault. The accused, who was a drug trafficker and debt collector for the Hells Angels, was one of four men who were involved in the kidnapping and assault of a man who had threatened him. In her reasons for sentencing the trial judge noted a number of mitigating circumstances. The accused had experienced a number of challenges in his personal life, including significant physical, emotional and sexual abuse. He became addicted to crystal methamphetamine which led him into further criminal activity. Since his detention he had been a model prisoner, completed extensive courses and given considerable assistance to other inmates and had excellent prospects for rehabilitation. The sentencing judge accepted that the accused’s guilty plea was a significant mitigating factor and imposed an effective sentence of four years." (Quoting from R v Tahvili, 2008 BCSC 22) Find other summaries.
R v Randhawa, 2007 BCCA 598 (CanLII), per Hall J	BC	CA		Find other summaries.
R v Deo and Mangat, 2007 BCCA 626 (CanLII), per J	{{}}			Find other summaries.
R v Ingram, , [2003] O.J. No. 3801 (ONSC)(*no CanLII links)	ON	SC		"a sentence of 4 years was imposed for offences of kidnapping and aggravated assault, which involved planning. The sentence of 4 years took into account credit of 3 years for pre-sentencing custody, so it was effectively a 7 year sentence. Another significant mitigating factor was the fact that the accused pleaded guilty."(Quoting from R v Tahvili, 2008 BCSC 22)
R v McBride, 2003 NSSC 204 (CanLII), per Kelly J	NS	SC	16 month CSO (JR)	The offender also sentenced for assault causing and breach of probation. He grabbed wife by throat and confined her in the vehicle. The offender had 14 prior convictions for violence against women. The sentence was a joint recommendation. Find other summaries.
R v Gbeve, 2001 MBCA 73 (CanLII), per Kroft JA	MB	CA
R v Pupovic, 2000 CanLII 16876 (ON CA), per curiam	ON	CA	2 years imprisonment	The offender bound and gagged his mother-in-law and put her in the basement. The victim was found and rescued by a neighbour. The offender appealed from sentence of 5 years.
R v Savchenko, 2000 CanLII 28797 (NLSCTD), 191 Nfld. & PEIR 225 (NLSC), per Adams J	NL	SC	18 months imprisonment	The offender was also sentenced for assault with a weapon, uttering threats, and unlawful entry. He entered into victim's apartment and forced them into a car and drove with the victim at knife-point, the victim escaped while the car was stopped. The offender had an unrelated record.
R v Twizell, 2000 BCCA 181 (CanLII), per Donald J	BC	CA		Find other summaries.
R v Chong, 2000 BCCA 359 (CanLII), per Southin JA	BC	CA	14 years imprisonment	Find other summaries.
R v Mills, 1998 CanLII 15020 (BC CA), per Donald J	BC	CA		"In Mills, two accused, Mills and Babin undertook to collect a debt for a third party. They grabbed the victim outside his work place, forced him into a vehicle, jabbed a loaded sawed-off shotgun in his side and threatened to kill him if he did not come up with the money. They then drove around for several hours in an inept attempt to collect on the debt. The police were alerted at a very early stage and brought the incident to a safe conclusion. The accused pleaded guilty to kidnapping for ransom before different judges. Mr. Babin was sentenced to four years. Mr. Mills received a sentence equivalent to five years when time spent in custody was taken into account." (Quoting from R v Tahvili, 2008 BCSC 22) Find other summaries.
R v Hiltz, 1998 CanLII 6235 (BC CA), per Lambert JA	BC	CA		"the accused and others kidnapped the victim under the pretence of appraising estate items. The victim was threatened with a gun and tied up in his own home. Mr. Hiltz spent 18 months in pre-trial custody. He received a sentence of 9 years for the offence of kidnapping with a firearm and concurrent sentence for other offences, including unlawful confinement, robbery with a firearm and assault causing bodily harm. On appeal the accused argued the sentences were unfit, relying principally on Mills." (Quoting from R v Tahvili, 2008 BCSC 22) Find other summaries.
R v Dorland, 1995 CanLII 2861 (BC CA), per J	BC	CA		Find other summaries.
R v Hui, 1995 CanLII 2836 (BC CA), per Hinkson JA	BC	CA	14 years imprisonment	Find other summaries.
R v Rowe, 1994 CanLII 10494 (NLSCTD), 126 Nfld. & PEIR 301 (NLSC), per Easton J	NL	SC	3 months (confinement)	The offender also sentenced for uttering threats, dangerous operation, and assault with a weapon. He confined wife in a vehicle. Find other summaries.